Potter Mountain House perfectly reimagines history and family living, originally built in 1837 as the Manorkill Methodist Church and now transformed into an extraordinary Greek Revival estate in Gilboa, NY. Set on 37 scenic acres in the Catskills with sweeping mountain views, this 6,242 sq. ft., five-bedroom, four-and-a-half-bath home was masterfully renovated by ICDT Studio in 2023. Its spacious great room with original timber frame, chef’s kitchen, library loft, and luxurious primary suite offer both striking design and comfort, while multiple entertaining terraces and a heated garage make it ideal for families. Priced at $3,400,000, this unique architectural gem combines nearly two centuries of heritage with modern elegance, ready for turnkey living just two hours from NYC.
Exterior View
A picturesque American home stands amid a sprawling green landscape, surrounded by rolling hills and dense woods with trees showing the red, orange, and gold hues of autumn. The house features classic white clapboard siding with a prominent steeple and tower, blending the charm of traditional architecture with a bright, welcoming appeal. Large multi-pane windows invite natural light, while the manicured front lawn and neatly trimmed shrubbery provide safe play areas and curb appeal for families. The property’s circular driveway makes access easy, and the serene rural setting offers a peaceful retreat with breathtaking views in every direction.
Backyard Exterior
A grand backyard view of a spacious white American home features large windows, a sunny open deck, and a charming cupola-topped roof, giving it a classic, inviting look. The multi-level layout includes a neatly manicured lawn, a retaining stone wall, and a cozy ground-level patio with seating perfectly arranged around a fire pit, ideal for family gatherings. Lush green trees surround the house, providing privacy and space for kids to play. The crisp white siding and orderly rows of windows offer a bright, welcoming facade, while the wide balcony serves as a perfect spot for outdoor meals and relaxing together.
Entryway Design
This spacious entryway features a welcoming and airy atmosphere with high, subtly textured off-white walls and a herringbone-patterned light gray tile floor. Natural light pours through large multi-pane windows, offering a bright view of greenery outside, perfect for family visibility. There is a practical built-in bench with a cushion for kids or guests to sit while putting on shoes, with wall hooks above that hold coats and scarves, highlighting everyday functionality. A rustic wooden table sits centered atop a warm-toned rug, showcasing a vase with flowering branches. Double white closet doors provide additional storage, and a classic lantern pendant completes the look.
Open Living Area
Spacious family-friendly living area with high vaulted ceilings featuring exposed wooden beams for a warm, rustic atmosphere. Two large burgundy sectionals with plush pillows anchor the sitting space, centered around a circular coffee table with decorative books and plants. A modern black suspended fireplace adds both coziness and style. Floor-to-ceiling windows line the room, allowing plenty of natural light, while plaid drapes offer privacy. The open layout seamlessly connects a generous wooden dining table and chairs, perfect for family meals. Light hardwood floors and a neutral color palette create a welcoming, airy vibe, and a mezzanine with a white railing overlooks the room, encouraging togetherness.
Family Living Room
Spacious living room featuring double-height ceilings and an abundance of natural light streaming in from tall, multi-pane windows along one wall. Rustic wooden ceiling beams add warmth and architectural interest, complemented by neutral-toned walls. A cozy, deep mauve sectional sofa is arranged in a U-shape around a modern, suspended fireplace, creating a welcoming spot for family gatherings. Soft accent pillows and throws enhance comfort, while the large round coffee table is perfect for games or snacks. Wall-to-wall plaid curtains and woven blinds add softness and privacy. Light wood floors and a geometric area rug complete the inviting, family-friendly space.
Open Kitchen Layout
Bright and airy kitchen seamlessly flows into an inviting family living area, making it ideal for gatherings and daily family life. The marble countertops and shaker-style cabinetry provide a clean, timeless look, complemented by natural wood accents and exposed ceiling beams for warmth. A large island offers ample counter space for meal prepping and family activities, while multiple windows allow natural light to pour in, enhancing the welcoming atmosphere. The space is organized for functionality, with hanging pots, neatly arranged utensils, and a cozy seating nook in the background. Neutral tones and soft textures make it family-friendly and easy to maintain.
Kitchen Window Area
This serene kitchen window area features a bright and airy layout with natural sunlight streaming in through a large central window framed by rustic wooden beams. Soft beige cabinetry with square panelled drawers provides ample storage, while the elegant white marble countertops and backsplash offer a touch of luxury. Above the stove, polished copper pots hang on a brass rod, adding warmth and a welcoming family-friendly touch. Potted herbs near the window encourage family cooking, and the open cookbook hints at daily life. The overall neutral color palette, blended with natural wood and soft whites, creates a calm, inviting ambiance for family gatherings.
Dining Area Loft
A spacious dining area with a cathedral ceiling and exposed wooden beams creates a welcoming atmosphere for family gatherings. The large wooden table, surrounded by ten matching chairs with high backs, is ideal for shared meals. Light wood flooring adds warmth, while neutral walls offer subtle contrast. Three arched doorways give character beneath a white staircase that ascends to a mezzanine library with built-in shelving. Tall windows draped with dark plaid curtains invite natural light, and a potted plant adds a touch of greenery. The open, airy layout ensures both style and practicality for families spending time together.
Home Library
A spacious home library is filled with tall, white built-in bookshelves stretching from floor to ceiling, organized and filled with an impressive array of colorful, neatly arranged books. Dominating one side is a handsome wooden ladder with metal rails, offering easy access to higher shelves—a practical touch for family members of all ages. Large natural wood beams cross the ceiling, adding rustic warmth and architectural character. Natural sunlight streams in from a nearby window, illuminating the room. The neutral cream walls, combined with the wood accents and soft light, create a cozy, inviting space perfect for quiet reading, study, or family time.
Family Living Room
A spacious, sunlit living room boasts soaring ceilings with exposed wooden beams and an entire wall of large windows, allowing natural light to flood the space. Soft cream walls and blonde wood floors create a warm, welcoming atmosphere. A central, modern wood-burning stove provides both a cozy focal point and warmth. Plush mauve sectional sofas, arranged in a U-shape around a round coffee table, invite family gatherings and conversation. The area is accented with neutral throw pillows and blankets, while patterned curtains frame the windows. Subtle touches like a side table, greenery, and gentle lighting provide comfort and family-friendly style throughout.
Cozy Living Room
A bright and welcoming family living room featuring a soft green sectional sofa arranged in an L-shape, perfect for gatherings or relaxing together. The seating is complemented by two eye-catching patterned cushions in vibrant orange and navy, adding a playful touch. Natural light streams in through a central window adorned with bamboo shades, illuminating the inviting space. The room’s walls are painted in a neutral, two-tone combination of creamy beige and taupe, creating a warm and soothing backdrop. A cozy white throw is draped over the sofa, and a glass-topped coffee table with a small bouquet gives a homey, inviting feel.
Powder Room Design
A charming powder room features a serene forest-themed mural in cool blue tones, creating a tranquil and inviting atmosphere. Natural light pours in through a window adorned with taupe linen curtains, softening the space and providing privacy. The vanity showcases a bold, dark stone sink paired with elegant brass fixtures for a touch of sophistication. Navy blue square tiles line the lower half of the wall, complementing the nature-inspired wallpaper above. Practical family-friendly elements include a sturdy toilet and accessible towel rack holding plush textured towels. Simple decorative accents and a framed mirror complete the functional yet stylish layout.
Bedroom Suite
A spacious and serene bedroom is shown, designed with a calming palette of beige and navy blue walls, complemented by light wood flooring. The bed features crisp white linens with a striped black and white throw, suitable for a family seeking comfort and relaxation. Natural light pours in through large windows, brightening the space and a small sunroom visible through double doors. The room is furnished with a vintage wooden dresser topped with vases of greenery, a mid-century modern nightstand, and a cozy reading chair. Stylish elements like textured furnishings, leafy plants, and a cloud-shaped pendant light add warmth and appeal for all ages.
Primary Bathroom Retreat
Spacious bathroom designed for both relaxation and practicality, perfect for a family home. Double vanities with sleek marble countertops are set in light wood cabinetry, allowing multiple users at once. The central freestanding bathtub and large walk-in shower, equipped with brass fixtures, offer luxury and accessibility. Checkerboard marble flooring contrasts beautifully with the navy blue walls and gold accents, adding a refined touch. Ample natural light pours in through wooden shuttered windows, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The room includes plenty of countertop space and mirrors, with additional thoughtful details such as decorative plants and elegant lighting fixtures.
Bathroom Retreat
A serene bathroom features a deep, freestanding white bathtub with elegant brass fixtures and a wooden caddy for relaxation essentials, perfect for unwinding after a busy family day. The space is surrounded by glossy marble tiles in shades of white and gray, giving a clean and timeless look. Warm wooden shutters on the windows add both privacy and charm while letting natural light stream in, brightening the room. A leafy green plant on a small wooden table brings a touch of nature inside, making the atmosphere fresh and inviting. Thoughtfully placed sponge decorations emphasize the calming, family-friendly environment.
Family Living Room
A spacious living room featuring a large, soft gray sectional sofa arranged in an L-shape, perfect for family gatherings or relaxing together. Natural light streams in through multiple windows with bamboo shades and blue plaid curtains. The neutral color palette is enhanced by light beige walls and pale wood flooring. A plush area rug and round orange accent pillows add cozy touches. The coffee table, topped with books and a small potted plant, sits at the center, while an arched built-in nook with shelves and cabinetry brings practical storage and display space. Open sightlines to the staircase and hallway create an inviting, open layout.
Living Room Details
Spacious living room with an inviting, family-friendly atmosphere. Large, plush gray sectional sofa wraps around a cozy area, complemented by round mustard-yellow throw pillows for a pop of color. A chunky knit cream blanket is draped over one arm of the sofa, adding warmth and comfort. The light hardwood floor is topped with a soft, patterned area rug, perfect for children to play on. Natural light streams through four wide windows dressed with woven wood shades and plaid curtains, illuminating the soft beige walls and tongue-and-groove wainscoting. An artwork featuring a sunlit forest creates a serene focal point above the seating area, while a wooden coffee table hosts books and a potted plant, enhancing the relaxed, lived-in feel.
Bedroom Retreat
A sun-filled bedroom with warm, earthy tones and a peaceful ambiance, ideal for families seeking comfort and relaxation. The room features a wide, plush bed with an upholstered beige headboard set against a two-tone wall in cream and terracotta colors. Textured beige and taupe bedding adds softness, complemented by multiple pillows for extra coziness. Natural light streams in through tall French doors, opening to the outside, enhancing the airy feel. The space is accented with a patterned red and white area rug, mid-century side tables, a wooden armoire, leafy houseplant, and classic framed artwork, creating a harmonious and welcoming atmosphere.
Bedroom Retreat
This cozy bedroom features a warm, neutral palette with cream and sage-green tones on the walls, enhancing a sense of calm and relaxation. A large wooden platform bed sits centrally, adorned with crisp white bedding, textured blankets, and soft, earth-tone pillows. Flanking the bed are two matching nightstands with woven lamps, providing ambient lighting ideal for reading. A comfortable tan armchair with a bolster pillow sits in one corner, offering additional seating. The French doors with grid-patterned curtains invite natural light and lead directly outside, perfect for families to enjoy fresh air. A large landscape painting and a plush area rug add warmth and visual interest.
Double Vanity Area
A spacious bathroom features two pedestal sinks side by side, each with polished brass fixtures and rectangular mirrors framed in dark wood above. The tiled walls display a sophisticated mix of cream, white, and deep green hues arranged in vertical and horizontal patterns, adding visual interest and warmth. Practical for family living, the setup allows multiple people to use the space comfortably at once. Decor includes a hand towel, liquid soap, a small decorative object, and a delicate vase with branches, lending a homely touch. The clean lines and thoughtful details create a welcoming, organized space ideal for family routines.
Children’s Bunk Beds
A cozy and thoughtfully designed children’s sleeping area featuring two built-in bunk beds, side by side, each with an upper and lower berth. The bunks are framed by elegant cream-colored archways, and each bed is fitted with heavy gold curtains for privacy. The beds are spacious and include plush bedding with soft decorative pillows. Behind each bunk, the accent wall boasts a woodland-themed wallpaper with rich brown, gold, and green tones for a warm, inviting atmosphere. A built-in staircase provides easy access to the top bunks. Soft wood flooring and a neutral area rug enhance the family-friendly comfort of the room.
Backyard View
A wide expanse of lush, green backyard bordered by dense woodland stretches into the distance, offering a picturesque and serene setting perfect for families seeking outdoor living. The gently rolling landscape features a well-maintained grassy area, ideal for children’s play or family gatherings, seamlessly blending into the surrounding mature trees for added privacy. Natural sunlight filters through a soft morning haze, creating a tranquil and inviting ambiance. The scenery is framed by distant hills, suggesting ample space for recreation and adventure. The predominantly green palette enhances the peaceful, rural charm, making the space both beautiful and family-friendly.
Listing Agent: Anthony Dargenzio of Houlihan Lawrence Inc. via Zillow
